Why Many Young Preachers Don’t Last — and How Churches Can Help Them Thrive
- Brent Madaris
- 13 hours ago
- 10 min read
When Calling Meets Reality
It has often been stated that nearly half of young men who enter pastoral ministry leave within their first five years. This statistic is sobering not merely because of the loss of numbers, but because of what it reveals: many who answer the call to preach are not being prepared, supported, or sustained by the churches that affirm them.
This is not a new challenge. Yet history shows us a different pattern — one where churches took shared responsibility for forming young shepherds rather than merely deploying them.
G. Campbell Morgan is a compelling example. Early in his preaching ministry, Morgan failed the formal ordination examinations of his denomination. Many would have interpreted this as a disqualification. Instead, trusted leaders and congregations recognized both God’s evident gifting and his immaturity. They encouraged him to continue preaching, growing, and learning. The result was a lifelong ministry marked by theological depth and endurance.
Likewise, Charles Haddon Spurgeon assumed the pastorate of New Park Street Chapel at just nineteen years old. Though extraordinarily gifted, Spurgeon lacked experience. Rather than placing the full burden of pastoral leadership on him alone, the elders surrounded him with counsel, shared responsibility, and patience. The church understood that calling does not negate the need for formation.
These stories stand in stark contrast to today’s reality — where young preachers are often launched quickly, isolated early, and evaluated harshly. The result is predictable: many burn out, become disillusioned, or quietly exit the ministry altogether.
The Scope of the Problem: Early Attrition and Its Cost
While exact figures vary and are often overstated in popular ministry literature, multiple studies and denominational reports have documented significant early attrition among pastors—particularly within the first five years of ministry. Older research and aggregated reports frequently estimated that as many as 40–50% of those entering pastoral ministry did not remain long-term, especially among younger or first-time pastors. More recent survey-based research suggests lower annual attrition rates among established pastors, though early-career pastoral turnover remains a persistent and costly concern. (1)
This loss has cascading effects:
Churches repeatedly cycle through short-term pastors
Congregations grow cynical and fatigued
Younger men observe instability and hesitate to pursue ministry
Communities lose consistent spiritual leadership
The problem is not merely a lack of calling — it is a failure of formation, expectation, and support.
So, Why Do So Many Young Preachers Not Last
Calling Is Confused with Readiness
Many young men are publicly affirmed in emotionally charged settings — such as conferences, youth rallies, or special meetings — where sincerity is equated with preparedness. While God certainly calls men through preaching, human affirmation is not the same as divine preparation.
When churches confuse zeal, and calling, with readiness, young men are often sent into pastoral roles without the theological depth, emotional maturity, or pastoral resilience required to endure hardship.
Isolation Replaces Mentorship
Historically, young ministers served alongside older pastors, learning by observation and correction. Today, many find themselves alone in difficult contexts with little guidance.
Isolation accelerates discouragement. Without mentors, young pastors lack:
Safe places to ask questions
Models for handling conflict
Perspective during failure
Sometimes, young preachers are taught the "stiff upper lip" ministry. They are subtly (and sometimes not so subtly) told not to be a whiner, but to toughen up, and straighten the church out. I have known some older pastors who seem to think it is a "right of passage" to see a young preacher thrown to the "wolves" and learn to "sink or swim."
When Mentorship is Present — But Ineffective
Yet isolation is not the only threat to young pastors. In some cases, mentorship exists in name but not in substance. Proximity must not be mistaken for guidance. Just because someone has access to a "mentor" doesn't mean that there is accountability. Some young preachers admire an older preacher and mistake that for mentorship. Yes, those we admire can form or shape us, but this is a far cry from biblical mentorship.
Let's face it. Not all mentorship is healthy. Poorly defined relationships can unintentionally reinforce pride, performance-driven ministry, or unexamined weaknesses. When mentors lack self-awareness, humility, or spiritual depth, protégés often inherit not only their strengths but also magnify their blind spots.
Effective mentorship requires more than availability; it demands intentionality, transparency, and a willingness to model biblical faith, repentance, patience, and endurance. Without these, mentorship can become another source of pressure rather than a means of support.
Unrealistic Expectations from Churches
Many congregations — often unintentionally — expect young pastors to be:
Visionary leaders
Skilled counselors
Administrators
Preachers
Community ambassadors
—all at once.
When inevitable shortcomings appear, disappointment sets in quickly. Instead of development, the pastor experiences quiet pressure or overt criticism.
Unhealthy Churches can "Kill" Young Preachers
Unhealthy churches are different from healthy churches, which simply need a pastor to lead them. In unhealthy churches, there are often deep-seated problems that are cyclical and resistant to change. Sometimes there are controlling forces within the church that seek to rule not only the congregation, but the pastor as well. At other times, there is immaturity and weakness in the church—yet that immaturity disguises itself as strength and stable faith.
New pastors, without proper understanding or awareness, walk into situations like these every day and find themselves—and often their families—traumatized in a very short time. It is easy to be blindsided when you have a heart full of zeal but little practical experiential awareness.
A Performance-Based Ministry Culture
In some circles, fruitfulness is measured almost exclusively by attendance, programs, or visible momentum. Young pastors internalize this pressure and begin to equate faithfulness with visible success. When results lag, discouragement can grow. They are left trying to "produce" to prove their validity and will sometimes veer off into "performance-based" ministry to keep the "numbers" up.
Pride in the Preacher
It is an interesting phenomenon to observe young preachers. Many I have encountered carry a noticeable swagger/confidence—sometimes bordering on arrogance—an air of certainty that suggests they have already figured ministry out. They are eager to show everyone how it ought to be done.
This spirit, however, is not limited to the young. I have seen older men display the same masculine bravado—sometimes men who have never pastored, some who have been in ministry for years. Some have never carried the weight of a wounded church or labored long in obscurity. Perhaps the language of battle is fitting here. Those who have never been to war often speak loudly of it. Those who have been there tend to speak less, and more carefully.
Pride in the preacher is a sure way to failure, for the Bible teaches that pride goes before destruction and a haughty spirit before a fall.
Family Implosion
The family begins strong, united, and hopeful—ready for the adventure God has set before them. In time, however, what once felt like an adventure begins to resemble a quagmire. The ground grows unstable. The dangers multiply. The threats are no longer theoretical.
The enemy does not aim only at the pastor. The wife is wounded—sometimes deeply. The children take fire and learn to limp long before they should. The pastor labors on with resolve and courage, but one day he turns and realizes the cost has reached his own household.
At that moment, the battle changes. As much as the pastor may desire to press forward, he cannot abandon his first charge. He must rescue his family. Retreat is not cowardice when it is ordered toward preservation. Sometimes the family withdraws to safe quarters for rest and recovery. Sometimes they return to the fight. And sometimes, for that family, the war is over.
How Young Preachers Are Sustained: A Shared Responsibility
Although I am well aware that God calls preachers, equips preachers, and sustains preachers there is more here that I want you to see.
1. The Role of the Local Church
The local church remains the primary context in which pastoral endurance is formed. Yet, this is precisely where the failure often occurs. Many churches are themselves unhealthy and offer little meaningful support to help young pastors survive and thrive. Instead of nurturing and stabilizing new shepherds, congregational dysfunction, misplaced expectations, and persistent discouragement frequently accelerate their exit from pastoral ministry. Churches must resist the temptation to view a young pastor as a finished product and instead commit to long-term cultivation.
Pastoral endurance rarely happens by accident; it is cultivated intentionally by churches that understand formation as a long-term responsibility.
Healthy churches that help young pastors endure:
Provide intentional mentorship and shared leadership, ensuring young pastors are not isolated or left to carry the full weight of ministry alone.
Set realistic expectations for growth and fruit, valuing faithfulness and steady progress over immediate visible results.
View young pastors as stewards in development, not finished products, allowing time for growth before assigning full responsibility.
Clarify expectations early, defining success biblically rather than numerically.
Create space for learning, correction, and even failure, treating mistakes as part of formation rather than immediate disqualification.
Model long-term ministry, celebrating endurance, humility, and perseverance more than innovation or platform-building.
The church must remember: ordination is not the end of formation; it is the beginning of accountability.
The churches that sustained Morgan and Spurgeon did not lower standards — they raised men into those standards over time.
2. The Role of Bible Colleges and Seminaries
Bible colleges and seminaries play an indispensable role in preparing young men for ministry. Many godly professors labor faithfully to ground students in Scripture, theology, and disciplined study. Yet academic excellence alone, however valuable, is not designed to carry the full weight of pastoral formation.
Schools serve young preachers best when they:
Pursue spiritual formation alongside academic rigor, recognizing that character, humility, and endurance must be shaped as intentionally as theological competence.
Expose students to the realities of pastoral life — including conflict, discouragement, and perseverance — through the involvement of seasoned pastors who have endured long-term ministry, complementing the strengths of academic instruction.
Model humility, patience, and long-term faithfulness, understanding that students often imitate what they observe more than what they are taught.
Maintain strong, intentional partnerships with local churches and alumni, ensuring that preparation for ministry remains tethered to lived pastoral experience rather than theoretical ideals alone.
The goal is not merely to produce graduates but to prepare shepherds who can endure unseen labor, difficult conflict, and delayed fruit.
In cases where a school operates under the authority or influence of a local church and its pastor, the responsibility for formation extends beyond the classroom. Students inevitably emulate the leaders they admire, often reflecting not only their strengths but also unintentionally magnifying their weaknesses. As in families, where children sometimes gravitate toward a parent’s vulnerabilities rather than their virtues, so too in ministry formation. This reality underscores the importance of self-awareness, humility, and accountability among pastoral leaders whose lives and methods quietly shape the next generation.
3. The Role of Senior Pastors and Mentors
Paul’s instruction to Timothy was not accidental: “The things that thou hast heard of me… commit thou to faithful men”(2 Tim. 2:2).
Experienced pastors play a critical role by:
Offering honest counsel, not just encouragement
Allowing young men to learn through responsibility, not abandonment
Modeling repentance, patience, and perseverance
Creating safe spaces for questions and failure
Young preachers rarely leave because of theology; they leave because they feel alone.
4. The Role of the Young Pastor Himself
Calling does not exempt a man from responsibility.
Young pastors must:
Cultivate humility and teachability
Receive correction without defensiveness
Guard their spiritual life diligently
Learn to endure obscurity and slow seasons
Resist comparison and performance-driven ministry
Continue to study, learn, and grow in all areas of life and leadership.
Endurance grows where character is prioritized over a platform or position.
5. The Role of the Pastor’s Family
Finally, the family must not be overlooked.
Wives often carry unseen burdens. Children absorb pressures they cannot articulate. Churches and leaders serve young pastors well when they:
Care for the family, not just the ministry output
Protect reasonable boundaries
Encourage healthy rhythms of rest and presence
A pastor who loses his family rarely lasts long — even if he remains in the pulpit. He must prioritize the life and vitality of his family. They must remain a primary ministry focus. He must shepherd them.
Final thought: From Attrition to Formation - From Calling to Cultivation
The loss of young pastors is not merely a statistical concern — it is a spiritual and generational one. When nearly half of those who enter ministry leave within a few short years, the issue is not simply individual failure, nor can it be laid at the feet of any single institution. Pastoral endurance is formed — or eroded — through a shared ecosystem of influence.
Churches must recover a vision of long-term formation rather than short-term deployment. Bible colleges and seminaries must continue their indispensable work while remaining tethered to lived pastoral realities. Senior pastors and mentors must model humility, patience, and perseverance. Families must be supported, not overlooked. And young pastors themselves must embrace teachability, resilience, and faithfulness in unseen seasons.
History reminds us that some of the most fruitful servants of Christ were not immediately ready, yet were patiently cultivated by wise churches and godly leaders. The goal was never to produce polished ministers quickly, but to form shepherds who would last.
The current pastoral shortage is not inevitable. It doesn't have to be perpetual. It is, in many ways, a mirror — revealing where formation has been rushed, expectations distorted, and support withdrawn too soon. If the church is willing to slow down, walk together, and recover the biblical pattern of shared responsibility, the next generation of pastors can not only survive — they can thrive.
The question before us is no longer whether God is still calling men to preach.
It is whether we are willing to steward those callings with patience, wisdom, and care.
_____________________
This article is part of an ongoing conversation about pastoral formation and sustainability. For a broader look at the scope of the pastoral shortage and the growing difficulty churches face in finding shepherds, read: “Where Are the Shepherds? Why So Many Churches Cannot Find a Pastor.”
Early attrition estimates frequently cited in ministry literature are derived from aggregated surveys, denominational data, and older research summaries rather than from a single longitudinal study. Contemporary research tends to focus on currently serving pastors and therefore may underrepresent early-career exits.
Coming Next
Calling or Crowds? Rethinking How Young Men Are “Called” Into Ministry
High-impact youth events and conferences have produced many sincere young preachers — but also a quiet crisis. When men are “called” by moments, pressure, or personalities rather than shaped patiently by God and the local church, the fallout often comes years later.
The next article will explore how calling culture, well-intended ministry events, and premature launches contribute to early pastoral attrition — and how churches and leaders can pursue reform without accusation.
Comments